Monday, 16 January 2017

Why do Putnam and Proctor get into an argument in The Crucible?

At first, Mr. Putnam and John Proctor argue about how dire the situation with the girls in Salem is. Proctor takes issue with the fact that Reverend Parris didn't consult anyone else in the village before he called for Reverend Hale, the witch hunter from Beverly. Putnam, however, has a sick daughter, and he says, "There be children dyin' in the village, Mister!"  And Proctor replies, "I see none dyin'. This society will not be...

At first, Mr. Putnam and John Proctor argue about how dire the situation with the girls in Salem is. Proctor takes issue with the fact that Reverend Parris didn't consult anyone else in the village before he called for Reverend Hale, the witch hunter from Beverly. Putnam, however, has a sick daughter, and he says, "There be children dyin' in the village, Mister!"  And Proctor replies, "I see none dyin'. This society will not be a bag to swing around your head, Mr. Putnam." In other words, Putnam accuses Proctor of not taking the situation seriously enough, and Proctor accuses Putnam of trying to manipulate the village. 


Then, Putnam instructs Reverend Parris to tell Mr. Hale to look for witches when he arrives, and Proctor declares that Putnam cannot "command" the minister. Proctor again accuses Putnam of trying to rule. Putnam accuses Proctor of not caring about society since he hasn't been "at Sabbath meeting since snow flew," and Proctor blames his absence on the subject of Parris's sermons: "only hellfire and bloody damnation." Why would he want to come each Sunday to listen to the same negative sermon again and again?


Next, Putnam takes Parris's side when Parris accuses Proctor of being part of a faction to remove Parris from his position.  Putnam declares that this faction moves against Parris "and all authority," to which Proctor declares that he'd like to find this party and join it. 


Finally, Putnam and Proctor quarrel over land. Proctor mentions his intention to take some lumber home, and Putnam accuses him of removing lumber from his land. Proctor declares that he bought the land from Francis Nurse some years ago, Putnam declares that his grandfather willed the land to him, and Proctor accuses his grandfather of giving away land that didn't belong to him (a claim that Giles Corey supports). In short, Putnam and Proctor fight about anything and everything.  

No comments:

Post a Comment

How are race, gender, and class addressed in Oliver Optic's Rich and Humble?

While class does play a role in Rich and Humble , race and class aren't addressed by William Taylor Adams (Oliver Opic's real name) ...