Saturday 23 December 2017

How are race, gender, and class addressed in Oliver Optic's Rich and Humble?

While class does play a role in Rich and Humble, race and class aren't addressed by William Taylor Adams (Oliver Opic's real name) in the book. There are no struggles or scenes devoted to gender roles, racial issues in society, or anything of that type.

Class plays the biggest role in the novel, because Bertha starts out as a upper-class girl living on a wealthy estate and is then cast out without a place to go, without friends, and without money. She has to work to prove her father's innocence and reclaim her estate.


Even before Bertha has to become a member of the working class, she has empathy for the poor. Adams writes of an area near Woodhill where Bertha lives: "This was Dunk's Hollow, to whose poor and neglected little ones Bertha Grant had become a ministering angel." She is kind and helpful to people in the social classes below her.


This is contrasted later when her origins are revealed to her employer Mrs. Byron. The woman likes Bertha as a governess until she finds out that Mr. Grant is in jail for fraud. Once that truth is exposed, she views Bertha as a liar, fraud, and thief, and tries to fire her without pay. Her treatment of Bertha, a servant, exposes the negative views of the privileged toward the working class.


Further, when Bertha is cast out by Mrs. Byron, a member of the servant class gives her a place to stay to make sure she's safe. Peter tells her that there's nowhere safe to stay nearby and invites her back to his home. He and his wife give her a comfortable place to stay, and he drives her to the ferry the next day. 


Adams also shows the contrast between two different societies near Woodhill. First, he describes Dunk's Hollow, saying:



Dunk's Hollow had a very bad name in the neighborhood and man, woman, or child who came from there was deemed a reproach to the race. There was only one shop at the Hollow, and that was the principal source of all its miserty, for its chief trade was in liquor, pipes, and tobacco.



Next, he describes another nearby town:



On the opposite side of the river was the thriving village of Whitestone, in surprising contrast with the place just described. It contained four or five thousand inhabitants, with all the appointments of modern civilization, including a racecourse, half a dozen billiard saloons, where better and liquor drinking were the principal recreations, and as many bowling alleys and fashionable oyster shops.



The contrasting descriptions of the two different communities shows the differences in how people see the different classes of people. For example, liquor is clearly seen as negative in Dunk's Hollow. Liquor in Whitestone is considered a part of modern civilization, set up to lure in the rich sons of the local estate owners.


Class plays a role in Rich and Humble as it contrasts the behaviors and actions of the characters. It also serves as the background of Bertha's struggle as she transitions from being a wealthy, cosseted girl to a member of the servant class and then, finally, back to wealth.

Why do the preacher's words disturb Brent in Whirligig?

The preacher's words disturb Brent because they reference his current situation. Like Cain in the Bible, Brent is essentially living in exile.


In complying with Mrs. Zamora's wishes, Brent basically becomes a sort of wanderer, perhaps even a "fugitive" from the kind of justice he thinks he deserves. He feels he should have been sent to the juvenile detention center instead of receiving probation. Above all else, Brent believes he deserves to be punished. The...

The preacher's words disturb Brent because they reference his current situation. Like Cain in the Bible, Brent is essentially living in exile.


In complying with Mrs. Zamora's wishes, Brent basically becomes a sort of wanderer, perhaps even a "fugitive" from the kind of justice he thinks he deserves. He feels he should have been sent to the juvenile detention center instead of receiving probation. Above all else, Brent believes he deserves to be punished. The text tells us that Brent's reaction to the preacher's words is grief; he recognizes the preacher's quotation from chapter 4, verse 12 of Genesis: "When thou tillest the ground, it shall not henceforth yield unto thee her strength; a fugitive and a vagabond shalt thou be in the earth."


The preacher's words remind Brent of his dismal situation, his culpability in Lea's death, and the loss of his innocence. Brent already feels like a fugitive from justice, and he definitely feels like a vagabond, someone who has no home. With one singular action, he knows he has wiped out the life of an innocent girl, and he must live with this knowledge for the rest of his life. To Brent, the preacher's words are disturbing because they reinforce his dismal situation and highlight his sense of living under divine condemnation.

If there was one thing that caused both WW1 and WW2 what would it be?

One thing that caused both WWI and WWII would be intense nationalistic feelings.  WWI was started when a Serbian nationalist shot the Austrian Archduke Francis Ferdinand in Sarajevo. Nicholas II of Russia felt as though he was the protector of all Slavs in Europe--this is why he backed Serbia in its war with Austria-Hungary.  Germany felt as though it should have had more status in Europe so it built up its military which led to...

One thing that caused both WWI and WWII would be intense nationalistic feelings.  WWI was started when a Serbian nationalist shot the Austrian Archduke Francis Ferdinand in Sarajevo. Nicholas II of Russia felt as though he was the protector of all Slavs in Europe--this is why he backed Serbia in its war with Austria-Hungary.  Germany felt as though it should have had more status in Europe so it built up its military which led to tension between Germany, Britain, and France.  


WWII would not have been possible without WWI.  Germany felt cheated by the Versailles Treaty and Hitler promised to restore the nation to past glory.  He stated that the German people were ideal and that they should own Slavic land in the East.  Italy felt as though their contributions for the Allied Powers in WWI were not appreciated enough so it backed Germany in WWII.  Mussolini wanted to recreate the Roman Empire and soon began to claim land along the Mediterranean for Italy.  Japan sought to drive out the European powers from Asia and create an Asia where Japan was the major power.  This led to tension between Japan and the United States.  

How are race, gender, and class addressed in Oliver Optic's Rich and Humble?

While class does play a role in Rich and Humble , race and class aren't addressed by William Taylor Adams (Oliver Opic's real name) ...