Friday, 3 June 2016

How did Larson use Burnham and Holmes to offer a commentary on two very different views on creativity and invention?

Daniel Burnham and Henry Holmes were both brilliant in some ways, but Burnham used his brilliance to create, while Holmes used it to destroy. Burnham was the architect who created the magnificent World's Columbian Exposition of 1893--a formidable feat, given the hurdles he faced to get it built. The results were so opulent that "some [visitors] wept at its beauty" (page 6). The fair also introduced visitors to new experiences, including the sights of Egypt...

Daniel Burnham and Henry Holmes were both brilliant in some ways, but Burnham used his brilliance to create, while Holmes used it to destroy. Burnham was the architect who created the magnificent World's Columbian Exposition of 1893--a formidable feat, given the hurdles he faced to get it built. The results were so opulent that "some [visitors] wept at its beauty" (page 6). The fair also introduced visitors to new experiences, including the sights of Egypt and the taste of Cracker Jacks. One exhibition hall had more volume than the U.S. Capitol, St. Paul's Cathedral, and several other large structures combined.


Dr. Henry Holmes (an alias), on the other hand, used the fair to showcase his capacity for malevolence. He constructed a hotel not far from the magnificent fair grounds that housed airtight vaults that were used as gas chambers. He also built a crematorium in the basement of his hotel. Holmes killed many young women who attended or worked at the fair, and he eventually admitted to killing 27 people (including three children). However, he may have actually killed more, as he dedicated his brilliance to causing death.


Larson alternates the chapters about Burnham with chapters about Holmes to contrast how Burnham worked to invent things that would bring joy to people, while Holmes used his considerable force and intelligence to create new ways to kill. The contrast between Burnham and Holmes is that Burnham used the new technology of his age to create, while Holmes, a devil-like character, used it to destroy.

No comments:

Post a Comment

How are race, gender, and class addressed in Oliver Optic's Rich and Humble?

While class does play a role in Rich and Humble , race and class aren't addressed by William Taylor Adams (Oliver Opic's real name) ...